Established in 2020 Thursday, January 28, 2021


Wild animal populations not declining as feared: study
Image: Rodrigo Ardilha, Unsplash.

by Marlowe Hood



PARIS (AFP).- The population of most wild animals with a backbone -- mammals, amphibians, birds, reptiles and fish -- is stable, scientists said Wednesday in a finding sharply at odds with a benchmark report issued every two years by environmental group WWF.

Looking at 14,000 vertebrate populations monitored by WWF since 1970, researchers found that if the one percent suffering the worst declines are removed from the equation, the remaining populations, grouped together, are holding steady in terms of overall numbers.

In September, the WWF's Living Planet Index reported an average 68 percent fall in the populations of all animals monitored, a grim figure that made headlines worldwide.

"Collapsing all population trends into a single value can give the impression that everything is declining," Brian Leung, senior author of the new study and a professor at McGill University in Canada, told AFP.

"However, the image of a global 'biodiversity desert' is not supported by the evidence."

There are in fact regions where most species within certain groups are on a clear downward spiral, such as birds in the Asia-Pacific region and reptiles in the Americas.

But including them in an overall average can be misleading, Leung said.

"The Living Planet Index metric does not actually show that 68 percent of all populations have been lost," he noted by email.

"Unfortunately, it is hard to not leave with that impression."

Asked to comment on the report, WWF referred AFP to the Zoological Society of London (ZSL), which co-authors the flagship Living Planet reports.

ZSL scientist Robin Freeman, also a co-author of the new study, published in Nature, acknowledged in a blog post that "removing these clusters (of extreme decline) leave a distribution of population that appears, on average to be stable."




'Get the science right'
"However, this doesn't mean that the remaining 99 percent of all populations in the Index are doing fine."

Freeman proposed yet another way of calculating the data to make his point.

Setting aside 10 percent of the vertebrate populations at both extremes -- those that have declined and increased the most -- "still reveals a decline of 42 percent since 1970," he said.

Leung was at pains to make clear that his findings do not suggest all is well in the animal kingdom.

"We are not arguing that there are no biodiversity problems, but rather that it is not all declining worldwide, nor hopeless," he said, noting that in some areas -- especially in temperature latitudes -- animal populations are increasing.

Nor does his methodology apply to last year's landmark report from the UN's science advisory panel for biodiversity, known as IPBES, which concluded that one million species on Earth are at risk of extinction.

Leung said he was concerned that his study might breed complacency or be deliberately misread to discredit conservation efforts to date.

"Our primary motivation is to get the science right," he said. "Over the long term, our field's credibility depends on it."

The fact that global populations of wild animals is more stable than thought should also be taken as an encouraging sign, he added.

"If everything is declining despite all of our efforts over the last few decades, this kind of continual negative messaging could cause despair and inaction," he said.

WWF has put out 13 Living Planet reports tracking changes in vertebrate populations since 1998.

© Agence France-Presse







Today's News

November 19, 2020

Merging stars produce glowing Blue Ring Nebula

World-first skin cancer treatment aims to help transplant patients

Study reveals how smoking worsens COVID-19 infection in the airways

Prehistoric shark hid its largest teeth

Scientists defy nature to make insta-bling at room temperature

Will small rockets finally lift off?

3D-printed, lifelike heart models could help train tomorrow's surgeons

Children produce different antibodies in response to new coronavirus

A DNA-based nanogel for targeted chemotherapy

Wild animal populations not declining as feared: study

Gene signature predicts whether localized prostate cancer is likely to spread

Study: Solar geoengineering may not be a long-term solution for climate change

Alzheimer's disease drug may help fight against antibiotic resistance

Gut microbiome manipulation could result from virus discovery

Antibiotic resistance genes in three Puerto Rican watersheds after Hurricane Maria

Scientists identify brain cells that drive wakefulness and resist general anesthetics

For neural research, wireless chip shines light on the brain

Stanford researchers combine Zillow and census data to determine residential water needs



 


Editor & Publisher: Jose Villarreal
Art Director: Juan José Sepúlveda Ramírez



Tell a Friend
Dear User, please complete the form below in order to recommend the ResearchNews newsletter to someone you know.
Please complete all fields marked *.
Sending Mail
Sending Successful