Established in 2020 Wednesday, March 27, 2024


Science has not kept pace with aquaculture
Aquaculture has reached unprecedented levels of growth in recent years, but largely without consideration of its impact on individual animals. Image: Pixabay.



NEW YORK, NY.- Aquaculture—the farming of fish, shellfish, and other aquatic animals for food—has reached unprecedented levels of growth in recent years, but largely without consideration of its impact on individual animals, finds a new analysis by a team of researchers.

“The scale of modern aquaculture is immense and still growing,” says Becca Franks, a research scientist at New York University’s Department of Environmental Studies and the lead author of the paper, which appears in the journal Science Advances. “Yet we know so little about the animals that we are putting into mass production, and the negative consequences of aquaculture’s expansion on individual animals will just continue to accumulate.”

The study is the first to systematically examine the scientific knowledge about animal welfare for the 408 aquatic animal species being farmed around the world—animals that include salmon, carp, and shrimp. The researchers found that specialized scientific studies about animal welfare—generally defined as an animal’s ability to cope with its environment—were available for just 84 species. The remaining 324 species, which represent the majority of aquaculture production, had no information available.

Animal welfare legislation is not new, but in recent years, governments have adopted laws aimed at enhancing enforcement and extending animal protections.

With traditional fishing on the decline, aquaculture has been touted as both a solution to food insecurity and as a means to reduce pressure on species in seas and oceans. However, the growth of aquaculture, or aquafarming, hasn’t diminished stress on wild populations. Meanwhile, as recently as 2018, 250 to 408 billion individual animals from more than 400 species were farmed in aquaculture—or about 20 times the number of species farmed in animal agriculture on land—according to the United Nations’ Food and Agriculture Organization.




The expansion of aquaculture raises concerns that the industry is moving ahead without sufficient knowledge of the animal life it is growing. The absence of this information signals risk because its operations and decisions are not scientifically based, the researchers note, and can lead to poor living conditions and suffering for the individual animals involved.

To explore this matter, the team, which also included Jennifer Jacquet, an associate professor in NYU’s Department of Environmental Studies, and Chris Ewell, an NYU undergraduate at the time of the study, sought to determine what research literature existed on the more than 400 species being farmed in 2018.

Their results showed that only 25 species, or about 7 percent of animals being farmed in aquaculture, had five or more publications on these animals’ welfare. By contrast, 231 species had no welfare publications while 59 had only one to four such publications. The remaining 93 did not have species-level taxonomic information, meaning it lacked sufficiently detailed findings on these species.

“While the presence of animal welfare knowledge does not ensure well-being, the absence of such information is troubling,” says Franks. “In sum, our research reveals that modern aquaculture poses unparalleled animal welfare threats in terms of the global scope and the number of individual animal lives affected.”

The authors emphasize that some aquatic animal species, such as bivalves, which include oysters and clams, may present fewer welfare concerns to begin with and may be a more promising avenue for production.

“Although aquaculture has been around for thousands of years, its current expansion is unprecedented and is posing great risks, but, because it is so new, we can choose a different path forward,” Franks says.







Today's News

April 11, 2021

Egyptologists uncover 'lost golden city' buried under the sands

Inside Covid vaccine production at BioNTech's new plant

Surgical sutures inspired by human tendons

Pollen wasp genus Quartinia produces silk for nest construction in desert areas

800-year-old medieval pottery fragments reveal Jewish dietary practices

Leaking calcium in neurons an early sign of Alzheimer's pathology

Artificial intelligence can accelerate clinical diagnosis of fragile X syndrome

Hands-free: Monkey plays video game - with its brain

Clever Delft trick enables 20 times faster imaging with electron microscopy

Science has not kept pace with aquaculture

Using molecular sieves to adjust the taste of non-alcoholic beer

All aboard! Next stop space...

Fighting dementia with play

New EU vaccine probe deepens Europe's Covid woes

Scientists reveal snow cover distribution in southern Altai Mountains

Good oral health reduces risk of fatal outcomes from

Research will contribute to the establishment of design methodologies for deep-sea infrastructure

New study: Goats more 'cognitively flexible' than sheep



 


Editor & Publisher: Jose Villarreal
Art Director: Juan José Sepúlveda Ramírez



Tell a Friend
Dear User, please complete the form below in order to recommend the ResearchNews newsletter to someone you know.
Please complete all fields marked *.
Sending Mail
Sending Successful